Triple Cheese Toastie Recipe

Prep time: 5 mins | Cook time: 10 mins

Introduction

Crispy bread, buttery crust, and a triple cheese filling that oozes with every bite. Mozzarella, cheddar and Gruyère melt together for the ultimate cheese pull moment. Simple to make and impossible to resist, this toastie is comfort food done right. If you love cheese you’ll love our 3 Cheese Toastie Recipe! Take your toastie to the next level with ooey gooey cheese, crunchy toast and truffle oil if you’re feeling a bit extra. Oozing with mozzarella, cheddar and gruyère cheeses and combined with our fresh Hi-Fibre Lo-GI White Block Loaf, this is one irresistible toastie to indulge in. Whether you’re enjoying it as a snack or as a delicious lunchtime treat, you’ll see why our 3 Cheese Toastie is a crowd favourite!

Ingredients

4 slices Hi-Fibre Lo-GI White Block Loaf
1/2 cup shredded mozzerella
1/2 cup shredded cheddar
1/2 cup shredded gruyère
salted butter

Method

Mix all 3 cheeses together in a bowl

Butter both sides of each slice of bread

On two slices of bread, layer a generous amount of the 3 cheese mix, then place the remaining slices on top

Place into a hot fry pan or toasted sandwich maker and cook until bread is golden and cheese is melted

Sprinkle the tops of the toasties with salt and enjoy while warm

Products featured in this recipe

Hi-Fibre Lo-GI White Block Loaf

View product

FAQs

For the best cheese for toasties, you’ll want something that melts well such as Swiss, fior di latte, Gruyère, Brie or tasty cheese. These will give you the best consistency to enjoy your cheese toasty. Whatever cheeses you choose, cheese toasties make a great lunchtime treat, so have fun experimenting!

To make a triple toastie, start with a bread that’s full of flavour and bite, like our Hi-Fibre Lo-GI White Block Loaf or a crusty Sourdough. Then you’ll need three kinds of cheese, each with different qualities. For stretch, mozzarella is a good choice, with a stronger cheese like tasty or vintage cheddar for bite. For your third cheese something with a different flavour profile like Gruyère will work best

Both grilled cheese and a cheese toastie are packed with melty cheese goodness, but there’s a key difference. A cheese toastie is made with two slices of bread, filled with cheese and toasted or pressed until crisp and golden. A grilled cheese is often pan-fried with butter, but still has two slices of bread and melted cheese inside. Some people also use “grilled cheese” to describe open-faced melts, but a toastie is always a proper sandwich. Either way, it’s hard to go wrong when cheese and bread are involved!

Ingredients